sign in a cave in Laos
Showing posts with label museum Lenggong. Show all posts
Showing posts with label museum Lenggong. Show all posts

27 March 2013

Lenggong archaeological gallery, again

Went back to Lenggong Musuem again - or I should say gallery, as that is now its new name.




New sign on the junction to the museum



However at the museum, the new signs have not been put up yet - there is still a blank white space below the roof
 the old name -


It has been 6 months since my last visit (see link above) and 8 months since I posted a general blog.

The upstairs gallery is now open. However it is not especially exciting, it is just a series of posters of Malaysian World Heritage sites and many posters on how Lenggong achieved its recognition. There are just 3 small display cabinets and a video.



There was one "politically correct" poster showing people praying for Lenggong to be inscribed as a World Heritage, and shows people of 4 religions praying - Muslims, Christians in a church, Chinese in a temple and Indians -



At least all the posters are recent and mention Bukit Bunuh at 1.83 myo (unlike the displays downstairs).


As usual the English on the posters wasn't proofread and there are mistakes.

© Liz Price
No reproduction without permission

4 October 2012

Lenggong museum now a gallery

I had a letter published in The Star on 4 October 2012, re Lenggong Museum now being called a gallery. I have already blogged this.

THE STAR
Thursday October 4, 2012
Lenggong Museum is now a gallery

THE Lenggong archaeological museum, Muzium Arkeologi, has changed its name to Galeri Arkeologi.

In other words, it is no longer a museum, but a gallery.

This is probably because Jabatan Warisan Negara took over Muzium Lenggong from Jabatan Muzium Malaysia on Aug 7.

Since this take over, all the road signs and signs at the museum are being replaced, with the word museum changed to gallery.

However, I wonder if anyone has bothered to check the meaning of the word gallery.

It has two meanings, one related to content, and the other related to structure.

A gallery is a room or building for the display or sale of works of art, or for the exhibition of artistic work.

Alternatively a gallery can mean a long room or passage forming a portico or colonnade.

Whereas a museum is a building in which objects of historical, scientific, artistic, or cultural interest are stored and exhibited.

It seems to me that gallery is an inappropriate word for the Lenggong archaeological artifacts. It may even suggest that the exhibits are for sale!

LIZ PRICE

Kuala Lumpur

3 October 2012

Lenggong archaeology museum now a gallery

When is a museum not a museum? When its a gallery!

The Lenggong Museum is now a Gallery!

The Lenggong archaeological museum in Perak, Muzium Arkeologi, has changed its name to Galeri Arkeologi. In other words, it is no longer a museum, but a gallery.

This is probably because Jabatan Warisan Negara took over Muzium Lenggong from Jabatan Muzium Malaysia on 7 August 2012. This came after the Lenggong Valley was inscribed as a UNESCO World Heritage site on 30 June 2012.

Since this take over, all the road signs and signs at the museum are being replaced, with the word museum changed for gallery.

The brass sign on the museum wall, signed by the Sultan has now gone
July (above) and September (below)


The main sign on the outer wall of the museum compound was actually removed earlier, first photo taken in 2003, 2nd photo in July 2012 -


The road signs have been covered over with the new name -

The new Jabatan Warisan signs -

On my most recent visit at the end of Sept I saw 3 new huge posters on an outer wall. Even those had the word 'musuem' covered over


However I wonder if anyone has bothered to check the meaning of the word gallery. It has two different meanings, one related to content, and one related to structure :
A gallery is a room or building for the display or sale of works of art, or for the exhibition of artistic work. Alternatively gallery can mean a long room or passage forming a portico or colonnade.
Whereas a museum is a building in which objects of historical, scientific, artistic, or cultural interest are stored and exhibited.

It seems to me that gallery is an inappropriate word for the Lenggong archaeological artifacts. It may even suggest that the exhibits are for sale!

See more on Lenggong Museum.

On 4 Oct 2012 I had a letter published in The Star about this change of name from museum to gallery.

© Liz Price
No reproduction without permission

29 July 2012

Lenggong Museum, Perak, Malaysia

The Lenggong Valley in Perak, Malaysia, was listed as a World Heritage site on 30 June 2012.

My last visit to the museum was in 2003, shortly after it opened.

I returned on 20 July 2012, just 3 weeks after Lenggong was listed as a WH site. I expected great things from the musuem, and was disappointed. There was no real mention of the WH status and the museum exhibits had not been updated since at least 2009.

In comparison the Perak Darul Musuem in Ipoh is far better. Earlier in 2012 it was set up to feature archaeology in anticipation of Lenggong getting the UNESCO listing. The result is good. I can't say the same about the Lenggong museum.

Using the highway from Ipoh, you take the Kuala Kangsar exit, but there are no signs about Lenggong. It is only after the toll that the first sign is seen. This says the museum is 33 km, but in fact it is at least 38 km, which would be confusing for those using gps.
Having turned off the main road you go past Kota Tampan village. There is a building site, which looks like it might be connected with the museum and the first signs of World Heritage.
At the junction to the museum is a large fake stone with a dark brown sign saying welcome to the museum.
Outside the museum I noticed the large sign on the wall was completely missing the name of the museum, only the address was shown. Compare with 2nd photo taken in 2003
The phone was also missing from the booth!
And disappointly there was no real mention of World Heritage, only this same sign which appeared in a few places
Department of National Heritage , Archaeology gallery, Lenggong Valley, our heritage, world heritage.
We parked by the fake boulder and the stench of air freshener from the toilet hit us. Since my last visit, the museum was moved into the adjacent building. The entrance is made to look like a cave entrance.
Again there was no real mention of the World Heritage status, only the notice in Bahasa Malaysia.
Entry to the museum is free. As we signed the book, the caretaker went in to switch on some audio visual displays.
It was interesting to see that the visitor numbers were very high on some days since the world heritage listing less than 3 weeks before.
The first audio visual is a welcome talk by Dr. Adi Hj Taha, who sadly passed away in Feb 2012. The screen is housed in a huge replica of an earthenware jar (3000 years old) found in Gua Harimau.
There are many wall displays like giant posters, containing historical photos of various digs.
We were immediately hit by noise pollution with 2 audio visuals on the go plus a recording of some gamelan type music which was totally unnecessary.
The visitor space was quite cramped and the wall displays a bit overpowering. There were 2 cabinets of tools used by archaeologists.

A further series of posters and then a time chart. I realised that the information has not been updated since 2009. Bukit Bunuh is listed as being 40,000 years old, Kota Tampan at 74,000, and Bukit Jawa at 100-200,000 years old. Considering that Bukit Bunuh was dated in 2009 to be about 1.83 myo, there is plenty of time to have updated the museum info.
Bukit Jawa Kpg Temeleng Lawin at the bottom as they are the oldest sites
Archaeological sites
The Gua Badak drawings are shown and because old historical photos were used, the results are not too good.
There is a display of stone tools but they are not individually labelled. Metal artefacts are shown on a poster.
Another chart showing the migration of Homo sapiens from Africa to Perak shows them leaving Africa 150,000 years ago, going via Yemen and being in Malaysia 70-74,000 years ago. The text describes Kota Tampan as being a wooded valley near Penang! No update to list Bkt Bunuh at 1.83 myo.
There is a large “diorama” in a display cabinet showing prehistoric families going about daily activities and then the corner of this room is devoted to Perak Man.
Unfortunately the display cases have sliding doors resulting in an overlapping of glass in the front, which made photo taking more difficult. The visitor then walks through a “polystyrene” cave.
Unfortunately one of the fake boulders is already breaking.
In the corner of the cave is a replica of the 11,000-year old Perak Man skeleton (the original is in the National Museum in KL). There is a lot of information about Perak Man around the cave walls.
The next room is Gua Teluk Kelawar. There are more models of people going about daily life in Gua Teluk Kelawar.
Uptil now all displays had been in Bahasa Malaysia and English. But now the charts on the diet of early man were only in Malay.
The Centre for Archaeological Research Malaysia is often mentioned, but this changed its name to the Centre for Global Archaeological Research, PPAG, in February 2009.
Next to be featured is Gua Harimau. A display shows a complete skeleton but only partial skeletons were found in this cave. Some of the Bronze Age findings and jewellery from Gua Harimau are shown.
In the next section are posters on rock paintings at Lenggong and Gua Tambun and maps of cave sites. And a replica of the 8000 year old Gua Cha skeleton.
Another old time chart again shows Bukit Jawa etc as being the oldest sites
A staircase leads to the upper floor but this is closed.

As soon as we left, the doors were closed for the long Fri prayer/lunch time.

The building next door is the old musuem, which I visited in 2003 (2nd photo is 2003).
I liked the toilet signs


We then walked outside to the geology park.

In summary - I hope some attempt will be made to update the information and features in the museum. Also the information boards often showed poor English - this really needs to be improved, especially if foreign visitors start coming in larger numbers to view the museum.

Although the museum is located at Kota Tampan there is no information of where the original dig site was.

© Liz Price
No reproduction without permission